patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Judge Small Asked to Step Down for 'Bias' Against Drunken Drivers

Judge who sent basketball star Jalen Rose to jail is known for being hard on first-time offenders, lawyer charges.

 

A local attorney is asking 48th District Court Judge Kimberly Small to recuse from an upcoming drunken driving case because she's too tough on first-time offenders.

Small is known for her record of "sending a message" to first-time drunken driving offenders by sentencing them to jail. Bloomfield Hills attorney Robert Larin cited Small's "inherent bias" and a precedent from 40 years ago in asking she step down from a case scheduled for Thursday, The Detroit Free Press reports.

“This is nothing more than an elected judge legislating from the bench,” California-based attorney Keith Davidson said after Small sentenced former U-M and NBA star Jalen Rose to 20 days jail last summer for rolling his vehicle with a passenger in the car.

During the sentencing of Rose on July 27, Small said she wanted to "send a message" to possible offenders. “You’re not here because you drank,” she said. “I don’t mind that … I do mind when you get behind the wheel of a two-ton vehicle and use it as a weapon.”

  • What is the appropriate punishment for first-time drunken drivers?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • a slap on the wrist - everyone makes mistakes
        8 (6%)
    • probation and community service
        51 (38%)
    • jail time - there's no excuse for driving drunk
        72 (54%)
    Total votes: 131
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: 48th district court, Drunk Driving, Drunken Driving, jalen rose, and judge kimberly small
Do you think Judge Small is too tough on first-time offenders? Tell us in the comments.

Ryan Eaton

8:13 pm on Wednesday, October 12, 2011

It only takes one drunk driver to murder a family and it only takes them one time to do it.

Reply

Leave a comment