On 911 Call, Grandson Pleaded for Help After Being Shot, Detective Testifies

Sandra Layne, a 74-year-old former schoolteacher from West Bloomfield, is being held without bond after being charged with murder in 17-year-old Jonathan Hoffman's shooting death.

BLOOMFIELD TOWNSHIP — Seventeen-year-old Jonathan Hoffman called 911 and pleaded for help after being shot in the chest, allegedly at the hands of his 74-year-old grandmother in their home in a gated community in West Bloomfield , according to police testimony at Sandra Layne's arraignment hearing Monday afternoon.

Layne, a former schoolteacher, was arraigned Monday with an open charge of murder in Friday's  a senior at Farmington Central alternative high school who previously attended North Farmington and Hillel Day School.

After waving to family, including her husband, in the courtoom,  Layne bowed her head and stood mute as a West Bloomfield Police detective described Hoffman's plea to a 911 operator and Layne's response after police reported to the scene.

"The subject stated that his grandma had just shot him in the chest and that he was going to die and he pleaded for help," Detective Brad Boulet testified in front of Judge Marc Barron. "At approximately the three-minute mark of the 911 call, the subject screamed and exclaimed he had just been shot again."

As officers arrived to the condo in Maple Place Villas where Hoffman lived with his grandparents, they heard several gunshots and ordered Layne to come out of the house, Boulet testified.

"While walking toward the officers, Ms. Layne exclaimed that she had just ,” Boulet said.

The Oakland County Medical Examiner's Office found that Hoffman had eight entry or exit gunshot wounds and two bullets still in his body, Boulet testified.

The teen was found upstairs, unresponsive. He was transported  him to Botsford Hospital in Farmington Hills, where he was pronounced dead shortly after 6 p.m. 

As part of the open murder charge, a judge will decide the severity of degree after the possibility of conviction. Layne, also facing felony firearms charges, could be sentenced to life in prison.

There's a question of whether Layne is competent to stand trial, Assistant Oakland County Prosecutor Jason Pernick said, but did not elaborate.

Defense attorney Mitchell Ribitwer stated that Layne, a married mother of five with nine grandchildren, worked as a schoolteacher and had lived in West Bloomfield for 30 years. "She's very distraught, upset, withdrawn," Ribitwer, a Royal Oak defense attorney, said after the arraignment. "The family is distraught and concerned. It's a difficult time for everyone."

Layne has not talked to investigators regarding the relationship she had with her maternal grandson or why he was living with his grandparents after his mother and father moved to Arizona, West Bloomfield Police Lt. Tim Diamond said.

"There were some issues with this young man," Ribitwer said. "I don’t know if he was on drugs at the time this happened, but it’s my understanding that there were drugs in the home. ... I’m not sure what the substance was, but it appears this young man may have been using or selling drugs."

Layne is scheduled to be back in court May 24 for a pre-exam conference before Judge Kimberly Small.

Funeral arrangements have been made at Ira Kaufman Chapel of Southfield.  Rabbi Joshua Bennett will officiate at 11 a.m. Tuesday with internment to follow at Machpelah Cemetery of Ferndale.

Read more

Ronald Wolf May 24, 2012 at 11:09 PM
I am not a doctor but possibly what the detective describes is the act of an irrational woman possibly with a mental problem such as vascular dementia. Jonathan needed help and his school, the police and his community failed him. His seperated parents in Arizona preocupied with a seriously ill daughter are definitey not to blame.
Larry Beauchamp July 02, 2012 at 11:29 PM
You don't get to decide who is to blame and who is at fault. Cut out the armchair medical "vascular" dementia BS. That's ridiculous. His school has an obligation to teach him, that's all. Hes probably a loser, and his grandma is probably nuts. He dies, she goes to jail. Justice is served all round.
Ronald Wolf July 07, 2012 at 10:45 PM
Larry, your asinine remarks are both obnoxious and ridiculous and so is the system that failed to take notice, and in my opinion is hiding the truth. Her mugshot alone says something is missing there. My next question is what gives you the right to dispense the final word?
Angelo July 20, 2012 at 10:16 PM
Larry beauchamp, you are a disgusting ingrate. Maybe if you died it would serve justice to your completely stupid comment you just left on this. How do you like it? You are truly disgusting and are a true example of trash.
Ronald Wolf July 21, 2012 at 04:22 PM
Are you sure you are not holding anything back Angelo? Anyway What you said is about how I felt when I first read Beauchamp's downriver BS.Thanks for calling it for what it is, pure trash coming from trash.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something